Peer Review Process

Journal SPEED (Sport, Physical Education and Empowerment) employs a double-blind peer review process, in which the identities of both the authors and the reviewers remain confidential. The entire process—from manuscript submission to the final decision—is conducted online via the OJS (Open Journal Systems) platform, ensuring that every step is documented and traceable.

1. Initial Screening

Editors review each submitted manuscript within a maximum of 7 days. The screening covers the following: Alignment with the journal’s focus and scope;

Adherence to the journal’s template and author guidelines;

Completeness of the article’s components (e.g., abstract, methodology, a minimum of 80% primary references, etc.);

Similarity, assessed using Turnitin. The maximum allowable similarity score is 20%, with no more than 3% from any single source.

Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements are either returned to the authors for revision or rejected prior to the formal review process (desk rejection).

 

2. Reviewer Assignment

Each manuscript that passes the initial screening is evaluated by at least two reviewers, subject to the following criteria:

Reviewers must possess expertise relevant to the manuscript’s subject matter.

Reviewers must be affiliated with institutions different from that of the author(s), with at least one reviewer coming from an institution outside of Universitas Singaperbangsa Karawang;

Reviewers must have no conflicts of interest with the author(s).

Before being sent to the reviewers, the author’s identity is removed from both the manuscript and the file metadata.

 

3. Peer Review

Reviewers  evaluate the manuscript—typically within 3–4 weeks—using a standardised journal review form. The assessment covers:

Novelty and scientific contribution;

Clarity of the research problem and objectives;

Appropriateness of the methodology;

Depth of analysis and discussion;

Alignment of the conclusions with the research findings;

Currency and primary nature of the references;

Quality of language and writing.

Reviewers provide substantive feedback and one of the following recommendations: Accepted, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Rejected.

 

4. Editorial Decision and Revision

The editor makes a final decision based on the reviewers' recommendations. If the recommendations from the two reviewers differ significantly, the editor may request the opinion of a third reviewer. Authors are given a maximum of 2 weeks for minor revisions and 4 weeks for major revisions. Revisions must be accompanied by a table responding to each of the reviewers' comments. Manuscripts requiring major revisions may be sent back to the reviewers for another round of review.

 

5. Final decision

The final decision—acceptance or rejection—is determined by the Editor-in-Chief and communicated to the author via the OJS (Open Journal Systems) platform. The average time from manuscript submission to the first decision is approximately 6–8 weeks.

 

6. Copyediting, proofreading, and publication

Accepted manuscripts undergo language editing, formatting according to the journal’s style, and layout preparation, followed by a final proofreading by the author, before being published with a DOI.